Blog Details

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Blog
  • Can an MSME File an Insolvency Case Against a Company for Unpaid Dues Under the IBC?

Can an MSME File an Insolvency Case Against a Company for Unpaid Dues Under the IBC?

Introduction:

Delayed payments can seriously affect the financial stability of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs). When a company fails to pay for goods supplied or services rendered, the outstanding amount can disrupt working capital, business operations and the ability to meet financial commitments.

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) provides a legal mechanism through which an eligible MSME supplier can initiate insolvency proceedings against a defaulting company.

Under the IBC, an MSME may qualify as an operational creditor and initiate proceedings under Section 9, provided the statutory requirements are fulfilled.

However, an unpaid invoice does not automatically entitle an MSME to commence insolvency proceedings. The minimum default threshold, nature of the debt, limitation period and existence of any genuine pre-existing dispute must be carefully examined.

This article explains the legal remedies available to MSMEs, the procedure under Sections 8 and 9 of the IBC, the role of the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council (MSEFC) and important Supreme Court decisions concerning unpaid operational dues.

1. Can an MSME Initiate Insolvency Proceedings Against a Company?

Yes. An MSME supplying goods or providing services to a company may initiate proceedings under the IBC if the requirements applicable to an operational creditor are fulfilled.

Under Section 5(20) of the IBC, an operational creditor is a person to whom an operational debt is owed. Section 5(21) includes claims relating to the provision of goods or services, including employment, and certain statutory dues.

Accordingly, an MSME may qualify as an operational creditor where it has supplied goods, rendered services or otherwise incurred an eligible operational debt that remains unpaid.

Examples include:

  • Manufacturers supplying raw materials or finished products.
  • Small businesses providing engineering or technical services.
  • Contractors executing commercial projects.
  • IT companies providing software and technology services.
  • Transporters and logistics service providers.
  • Suppliers undertaking maintenance, repair or other business services.

The creditor’s MSME status does not automatically establish the right to commence insolvency proceedings. The nature of the debt and the statutory requirements under the IBC must still be satisfied.

2. What Is the Minimum Outstanding Amount Required Under the IBC?

One of the most important conditions is the minimum default threshold.

Under Section 4 of the IBC, the minimum amount of default for initiating corporate insolvency resolution proceedings is ₹1 crore.

This threshold was increased from ₹1 lakh to ₹1 crore with effect from 24 March 2020 through Notification No. S.O. 1205(E).

Therefore, an MSME seeking to initiate a Section 9 application must establish an eligible operational default of at least ₹1 crore.

Illustration:

Suppose an MSME supplies machinery components to a private limited company and raises several unpaid invoices:

Particulars Amount
Invoice 1 ₹35 lakh
Invoice 2 ₹30 lakh
Invoice 3 ₹25 lakh
Invoice 4 ₹20 lakh
Total outstanding principal ₹1.10 crore

If the invoices represent a genuine operational debt, the amount is due and payable, and the other requirements of the IBC are satisfied, the MSME may consider initiating proceedings under Section 9.

However, merely adding invoices or interest figures does not establish that the threshold is met. The amount must represent a legally enforceable default, and any interest included in the calculation must have an appropriate contractual or legal basis.

Important: An outstanding amount below ₹1 crore does not ordinarily qualify for a Section 9 application under the present threshold. The MSME may nevertheless have recovery remedies under the MSMED Act, civil law or other applicable legislation.

3. Demand Notice and Insolvency Proceedings Under Sections 8 and 9

The IBC prescribes a statutory process for operational creditors seeking to initiate corporate insolvency resolution proceedings.

Under Section 8, an operational creditor must first deliver a demand notice of unpaid operational debt or a copy of the invoice demanding payment to the corporate debtor. The prescribed forms are Form 3 and Form 4 under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority) Rules, 2016.

The demand notice should clearly identify the parties, the underlying commercial transactions, the unpaid invoices, the amount claimed and the date of default. Proof of delivery should be preserved.

Upon receipt of the notice, the corporate debtor has 10 days under Section 8(2) to bring to the creditor’s notice the existence of a dispute, together with the record of pending proceedings relating to that dispute, or to provide evidence that the unpaid operational debt has been paid.

Where payment is not received and no qualifying pre-existing dispute is established, the operational creditor may consider filing an application under Section 9 before the appropriate National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT).

The application must comply with the prescribed requirements and be supported by the relevant invoices, demand notice, proof of service, evidence of default, applicable affidavits and other prescribed documents.

The NCLT examines the application in accordance with the IBC. Admission may result in commencement of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP).

4. Can a Company Avoid Insolvency Proceedings by Raising a Dispute Over the Invoices?

A genuine pre-existing dispute is an important defence available to a corporate debtor under the IBC.

Under Sections 8 and 9, an application may be rejected where a qualifying dispute existed before receipt of the demand notice and is supported by a genuine factual or legal basis.

For example, a company may have raised a documented complaint before the demand notice concerning:

  • Defective or substandard goods.
  • Short supply of materials.
  • Incomplete contractual work.
  • Failure to meet agreed specifications.
  • Incorrect billing or disputed quantities.
  • Breach of contractual obligations.

However, a company cannot necessarily defeat an insolvency application merely by raising an unsupported allegation after receiving the demand notice.

The distinction between a genuine dispute and an artificial defence is important.

Supreme Court’s position: Mobilox Innovations v. Kirusa Software

In Mobilox Innovations Private Limited v. Kirusa Software Private Limited, (2018) 1 SCC 353, the Supreme Court explained the test for examining a pre-existing dispute in an application under Section 9.

The adjudicating authority must determine whether a real dispute existed before the demand notice. It is not required to conduct a full trial on the merits of that dispute at the admission stage.

A defence that is merely hypothetical, illusory or unsupported may not be sufficient to defeat the application.

Important Supreme Court Judgement: Saraswati Wire and Cable Industries v. Mohammad Moinuddin Khan (2025)

In M/s. Saraswati Wire and Cable Industries v. Mohammad Moinuddin Khan and Others, 2025 INSC 1410, decided on 10 December 2025, the Supreme Court examined the rejection of a Section 9 application on the ground of an alleged pre-existing dispute.

The operational creditor, a registered partnership firm, had supplied goods to the corporate debtor and relied on its outstanding invoices and the debtor’s own ledger records.

The corporate debtor raised objections concerning alleged defective supplies, short supply and certain invoices. However, the Supreme Court found that the alleged disputes did not have a credible foundation sufficient to defeat the insolvency application. The debtor’s own ledger reflected substantial outstanding dues, and payments had continued despite the alleged grievances.

The Supreme Court set aside the NCLAT’s decision and restored the NCLT’s order admitting the Section 9 application.

Legal significance: A corporate debtor cannot defeat a genuine operational debt by relying on a merely illusory or unsupported dispute. The existence and substance of the alleged dispute must be examined against the contemporaneous records and conduct of the parties.

This decision is particularly relevant to MSMEs and other suppliers dealing with companies that acknowledge outstanding balances but subsequently raise questionable objections to avoid payment.

5. Can an MSME Approach the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council (MSEFC)?

Yes. In addition to the IBC, eligible micro and small enterprises may seek relief under the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (MSMED Act).

The Act provides a specialised mechanism for addressing delayed payments to qualifying micro and small enterprise suppliers.

Section 15: Buyer’s liability to make payment

Under Section 15, a buyer is required to make payment to the supplier by the agreed date.

However, the agreed payment period cannot exceed 45 days from the date of acceptance or deemed acceptance of the goods or services.

Where there is no written agreement, payment must be made before the statutory appointed day.

Section 16: Interest on delayed payment

Where a buyer fails to make payment as required under Section 15, the buyer becomes liable to pay compound interest with monthly rests at three times the bank rate notified by the Reserve Bank of India.

This statutory interest mechanism can be an important financial remedy for eligible micro and small enterprises.

Section 17: Recovery of the amount due

Section 17 provides for recovery of the amount due for goods supplied or services rendered, together with the interest payable under Section 16.

Section 18: Reference to the MSEFC

An eligible supplier may make a reference to the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council for resolution of a dispute concerning amounts due under Section 17.

The Council may undertake conciliation itself or refer the matter to an institution or centre providing alternative dispute resolution services.

If conciliation fails, the matter may proceed to arbitration under the statutory mechanism.

Section 19: Deposit requirement for challenging an award

Where a buyer seeks to challenge an award made under the MSMED Act, Section 19 generally requires a deposit of 75% of the amount payable under the award before the court entertains the application for setting it aside, subject to the statutory provisions.

This requirement is an important feature of the MSMED Act’s delayed-payment framework.

6. IBC Proceedings or MSEFC Proceedings: Which Remedy Should an MSME Choose?

The choice depends on the amount outstanding, the nature of the dispute, the status of the enterprise and the commercial objective of the creditor.

Factor IBC – Section 9 MSMED Act – Section 18
Primary purpose Initiation of corporate insolvency resolution Resolution and recovery of eligible delayed-payment claims
Eligible creditor Operational creditor Qualifying micro or small enterprise supplier
Minimum monetary threshold ₹1 crore default No equivalent ₹1 crore threshold
Main forum NCLT MSEFC
Initial procedure Section 8 demand notice Reference to MSEFC
Dispute consideration Pre-existing dispute is a significant admission issue Conciliation and, if required, arbitration
Interest Depends on legally established operational debt Statutory compound interest under Section 16
Potential outcome CIRP following admission Settlement or arbitral award

An MSME should not assume that one remedy automatically excludes the other in every situation. The effect of parallel proceedings, the nature of the claim, any existing insolvency process and applicable legal principles must be examined before choosing a course of action.

7. Does MSME Registration Matter for Filing a Section 9 IBC Application?

MSME registration is important, but it is necessary to distinguish between the rights available under the IBC and the special protections under the MSMED Act.

Under the IBC, the right to initiate proceedings as an operational creditor depends on the existence of an eligible operational debt and satisfaction of the statutory requirements. The IBC does not create a separate Section 9 procedure exclusively for MSMEs.

An enterprise may qualify as an operational creditor based on the nature of the goods supplied or services rendered, subject to the Code.

However, the special delayed-payment protections under Sections 15 to 24 of the MSMED Act are directed towards qualifying micro and small enterprise suppliers.

The date and validity of registration may be important when determining entitlement to those protections.

In Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Limited v. Mahakali Foods Private Limited (Unit 2), (2023) 6 SCC 401, the Supreme Court considered the statutory framework governing the MSMED Act and the effect of registration under the legislation.

Accordingly, businesses should examine their registration status, classification and relevant dates before relying on the special statutory benefits available to micro and small enterprises.

8. What Happens After the NCLT Admits a Section 9 Application?

Admission of a Section 9 application has significant legal and commercial consequences for the corporate debtor.

Once the application is admitted:

  • The Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process commences.
  • An interim resolution professional is appointed.
  • A moratorium under Section 14 generally comes into effect.
  • Proceedings and actions covered by the moratorium are restricted.
  • Management of the corporate debtor’s affairs is taken over in accordance with the IBC.
  • Claims of creditors are invited and verified.
  • The resolution process is undertaken under the supervision of the insolvency professional and the statutory framework.

The objective of the IBC is resolution of insolvency and maximisation of value, rather than simply providing a debt-recovery mechanism for an individual creditor.

An MSME should therefore understand that filing an insolvency application is not the same as filing an ordinary recovery suit. Admission can affect the management and operations of the corporate debtor and the rights of all creditors.

9. What Documents Should an MSME Preserve Before Taking Legal Action?

A properly organised documentary record can assist in evaluating a delayed-payment claim.

An MSME should ordinarily preserve:

  1. Valid Udyam Registration Certificate, where applicable.
  2. Certificate of incorporation, partnership documents or proprietorship details.
  3. Purchase orders and work orders.
  4. Supply agreements and service contracts.
  5. Tax invoices and delivery challans.
  6. Goods-receipt notes and proof of delivery.
  7. Work-completion certificates.
  8. GST returns and relevant tax records.
  9. Ledger statements and account confirmations.
  10. Bank statements showing payments received and outstanding balances.
  11. Emails and written acknowledgments from the buyer.
  12. Previous payment reminders and legal correspondence.
  13. Documents relating to any alleged dispute or quality objection.
  14. Details of any pending suit, arbitration or other proceedings.

The documents should be reviewed together to establish the contractual relationship, the amount legally due, the date of default and whether a dispute existed before the Section 8 notice.

10. Limitation Period: How Long Can an MSME Wait Before Filing?

Limitation is an important consideration in insolvency proceedings.

Under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, an application under the IBC is generally subject to a limitation period of three years from the date the right to apply accrues, ordinarily linked to the date of default.

The Supreme Court in B.K. Educational Services Private Limited v. Parag Gupta and Associates, (2019) 11 SCC 633, confirmed the applicability of the Limitation Act to proceedings under the IBC.

A written acknowledgment of liability before expiry of limitation may have consequences under Section 18 of the Limitation Act. Part-payment may also have consequences under Section 19 where its statutory conditions are fulfilled.

However, issuing repeated payment reminders or negotiating with the debtor does not automatically extend the limitation period.

An MSME should therefore identify the date of default for each relevant claim and examine acknowledgments, part-payments and any applicable legal extensions before initiating proceedings.

11. Common Legal and Documentation Issues in MSME Recovery Claims

Businesses may weaken otherwise maintainable claims through procedural or documentary errors.

Common issues include:

  • Filing a Section 9 application without first complying with Section 8.
  • Assuming that every unpaid invoice qualifies for insolvency proceedings.
  • Ignoring the ₹1 crore minimum default threshold.
  • Failing to verify the correct legal identity of the corporate debtor.
  • Relying only on self-prepared ledger statements without supporting transaction records.
  • Overlooking earlier correspondence concerning defective goods or incomplete services.
  • Including unsupported interest calculations to cross the statutory threshold.
  • Ignoring limitation.
  • Failing to preserve proof of delivery of the demand notice.
  • Treating insolvency proceedings as an ordinary debt-recovery threat.

A careful legal review before filing can help identify these issues and avoid unnecessary proceedings.

12. How Allies for Justice (AFJ) Can Assist MSMEs in Unpaid-Dues and Insolvency Matters

Delayed payments can affect an MSME’s working capital, employee salaries, vendor obligations and ability to continue business operations.

Where a company fails to pay legitimate commercial dues, an appropriate legal strategy requires examination of the underlying contract, invoices, payment history, applicable statutory remedies and the financial position of the debtor.

Allies for Justice (AFJ) & Partners, Advocates & Legal Consultants, undertakes legal work in areas relating to commercial disputes, insolvency matters, MSME delayed payments and recovery proceedings.

Depending on the facts and scope of engagement, legal assistance may include:

Legal assessment of outstanding dues: Reviewing purchase orders, invoices, contracts, account statements and acknowledgments to assess the legal basis of the outstanding claim.

Section 8 IBC demand notices: Preparation and service of demand notices under Section 8 of the IBC in accordance with the applicable statutory requirements.

Section 9 IBC proceedings: Legal assessment, preparation and representation in applications before the appropriate NCLT for initiation of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process.

MSME delayed-payment proceedings: Examination of remedies under Sections 15 to 19 of the MSMED Act, including references before the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council.

Commercial recovery litigation: Legal assistance in appropriate recovery suits, summary suits, arbitration proceedings and related commercial disputes.

Defence against disputed claims: Examination of contractual disputes, alleged defective supplies, counterclaims and other issues arising in insolvency or recovery proceedings.

The appropriate remedy depends on the facts, documents, limitation and statutory requirements of the individual matter.

Allies for Justice (AFJ) & Partners
Advocates & Legal Consultants

Website: www.alliesforjustice.com
Email: alliesforjustice.afj@gmail.com
Contact: 8527706198 | 8285728233

 

Disclaimer: This article is intended solely for general legal awareness and informational purposes. It does not constitute legal advice or create an advocate-client relationship. The outcome of any dispute depends on its specific facts, applicable statutory provisions and judicial interpretation.

Decision Are A Professional Attorney & Lawyers Services Provider Institutions. Suitable For Law Firm, Injury Law, Traffic Ticket Attorney, Legacy And More.

Contact Info

+91 8527706198
+91 8506079988
alliesforjustice.afj@gmail.com

Follow Us

This website is a public resource for general information about the material on our website that has been prepared and published for general information only. The information contained in this website is provided by Allies for Justice as general information that may or may not reflect the most current legal developments. Moreover, SDC Allies for Justice doesn’t give any guarantees, undertaking or warranties concerning the accuracy, completeness, or up-to-date nature of the information provided on this website.