Understanding False Promise of Marriage, Consent and Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023
A relationship may begin with love, trust and an intention to marry, but circumstances can change. When a couple has a live-in relationship or a consensual physical relationship and later separates, a legal question may arise: Can the man be prosecuted for rape because he had promised to marry the woman?
The answer depends on the facts, the nature of consent and the intention behind the alleged promise. A relationship ending or a promise of marriage not being fulfilled does not automatically make consensual sexual intercourse rape. However, a promise allegedly made with no intention of fulfilling it from the beginning may attract criminal liability under the applicable law.
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), which came into force on 1 July 2024, specifically addresses sexual intercourse by deceitful means under Section 69.
1. Is a live-in relationship legal in India?
Yes. Two consenting adults can choose to live together without getting married. A live-in relationship between adults is not, by itself, a criminal offence.
The Supreme Court has recognised the importance of personal liberty, individual choice and the right of adults to make decisions about their relationships.
However, being in a live-in relationship does not mean that either partner gives permanent or unlimited consent to sexual activity. Consent must be voluntary and must be assessed in relation to the particular circumstances.
2. Can a man be accused of rape after a live-in relationship?
Yes, a complaint can be made, and criminal proceedings may follow if the allegations disclose the ingredients of an offence.
However, the mere fact that a man and woman lived together, had a consensual physical relationship and later separated does not automatically establish rape.
The court may examine:
- Whether the woman voluntarily consented to the physical relationship.
- Whether consent was obtained through force, coercion, fear or a legally recognised misconception.
- Whether the promise of marriage was allegedly false from the very beginning.
- Whether the promise was the basis on which consent was given.
- Whether the relationship was consensual and whether the available evidence supports the allegations.
- Whether the facts disclose rape under Section 63 BNS or an offence under Section 69 BNS.
Each case must be assessed on its own facts. A live-in relationship is neither automatic proof of consent to every sexual act nor automatic proof of a criminal offence.
3. What does Section 69 of the BNS say?
Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 deals with sexual intercourse by employing deceitful means or by making a promise to marry a woman without any intention of fulfilling that promise, where the intercourse does not amount to the offence of rape.
The provision covers deceitful means, including certain forms of false promises, and prescribes imprisonment which may extend to ten years and also fine.
An important distinction is that Section 69 creates a separate offence. It is not itself the offence of rape.
Therefore, when a complaint concerns a promise of marriage, the precise allegations and the legal ingredients of the relevant offence must be examined.
4. What is the difference between a false promise and a genuine promise that was not fulfilled?
This is one of the most important questions in these cases.
A. False promise from the beginning
If a person allegedly promises marriage despite having no intention of ever fulfilling that promise, and uses it to induce sexual intercourse, the conduct may attract Section 69 BNS, provided its other legal ingredients are established.
B. Genuine promise followed by a change in circumstances
A person may genuinely intend to marry but later be unable to do so because of family opposition, personal circumstances or other genuine reasons.
A subsequent refusal or failure to marry does not, by itself, establish that the original promise was fraudulent.
C. Consensual relationship that later breaks down
If two adults enter into a consensual relationship and subsequently decide to separate, the breakdown of that relationship alone does not establish rape or deceitful sexual intercourse.
The court must consider the evidence and the circumstances existing when the promise was allegedly made.
5. Important Supreme Court judgment: Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani v. State of Gujarat (2026)
In Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani v. State of Gujarat & Anr., 2026 INSC 987, decided on 7 September 2026, the Supreme Court examined allegations involving sexual intercourse allegedly based on a promise of marriage.
The complainant alleged that the accused had entered into a physical relationship with her after expressing a desire to marry her, but later refused to marry because his mother did not approve of the relationship.
The Supreme Court examined the allegations and found that the complaint disclosed a consensual relationship without sufficient material showing that the accused had induced sexual intercourse through deceitful conduct.
The Court clarified that Section 69 BNS addresses fraudulent or deceitful conduct and that a promise to marry must have been made without an intention of fulfilling it.
The Court ultimately quashed the FIR.
Legal significance: A subsequent refusal to marry, particularly where the facts indicate that the promise was initially genuine, does not automatically constitute an offence under Section 69 BNS.
The judgment is important for understanding the distinction between a failed relationship and criminal deception.
6. Can a woman file a rape complaint if the man refuses to marry her?
A woman can approach the police if she believes that an offence has been committed. The police must assess the allegations under the applicable criminal law.
However, the legal classification depends on the facts.
- If sexual intercourse allegedly occurred without consent or under circumstances covered by Section 63 BNS, the rape provisions may apply.
- If the allegation concerns sexual intercourse obtained through deceitful means or a promise to marry made without any intention of fulfilling it, Section 69 BNS may be relevant where the conduct does not amount to rape.
- If the relationship was consensual and the marriage promise was genuine when made, a subsequent disagreement or separation alone does not establish either offence.
A complaint must not be dismissed merely because the parties were in a live-in relationship. Equally, the existence of a failed relationship cannot, by itself, establish criminal guilt.
7. What should a man do if a false rape case is registered after a live-in relationship?
A person facing a criminal complaint should act carefully and seek legal advice at the earliest stage.
The following steps may be relevant:
1. Preserve communication records
Preserve relevant messages, emails, call records and other communications. Do not delete or alter potentially relevant material.
2. Preserve evidence of the relationship
Where legally relevant, retain records that may establish the timeline and circumstances of the relationship, including travel records, accommodation records and other genuine documents.
3. Do not threaten or contact the complainant improperly
Avoid intimidation, pressure, harassment or attempts to influence witnesses. Such conduct may create additional legal complications.
4. Cooperate with lawful investigation
Respond to lawful notices and seek legal advice before making detailed statements or taking procedural steps.
5. Examine the ingredients of the alleged offence
An advocate should examine the FIR, complaint, supporting material and applicable statutory provisions to determine whether the allegations disclose an offence.
6. Consider appropriate legal remedies
Depending on the facts and stage of proceedings, remedies may include anticipatory bail under Section 482 BNSS, regular bail or an appropriate petition for quashing under Section 528 BNSS.
The availability of any remedy depends on the individual facts and applicable law.
8. What evidence can be relevant in a false-promise-of-marriage case?
The court may consider the complete circumstances rather than relying on one isolated message or event.
Potentially relevant material may include:
- Messages and communications discussing marriage.
- The timeline of the relationship.
- Evidence relating to the parties’ meetings and interactions.
- Communications showing the circumstances in which the relationship ended.
- Relevant statements and witness accounts.
- Other material demonstrating whether the promise was genuine or allegedly deceptive from the outset.
The evidentiary value of each item depends on its authenticity, admissibility and relevance. No single category of evidence automatically determines the outcome.
9. Important legal distinction: Section 63 and Section 69 BNS
| Legal provision | Subject |
|---|---|
| Section 63 BNS | Definition of rape |
| Section 69 BNS | Sexual intercourse by deceitful means or a promise to marry without intention of fulfilling it, where the conduct does not amount to rape |
| Section 28 BNS | Consent given under fear or misconception of fact |
| Section 482 BNSS | Anticipatory bail |
| Section 528 BNSS | Inherent powers of the High Court |
The applicable provision must be determined after examining the facts, the date of the alleged conduct and the ingredients of the offence.
10. Conclusion
A live-in relationship is a personal choice between consenting adults. When such a relationship ends, the parties may face emotional, financial and legal difficulties.
However, the law distinguishes between a genuine relationship that fails and a relationship allegedly founded on deliberate deception.
The Supreme Court’s decision in Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani v. State of Gujarat reinforces the importance of examining the intention behind a promise of marriage and the actual circumstances in which consent was given.
Neither a man nor a woman should be judged merely on the basis of allegations. Every case must be examined through evidence, statutory requirements and the principles of a fair investigation and trial.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1. Can a man be arrested for rape after a live-in relationship ends?
An arrest may be made where the legal requirements for arrest are satisfied. However, the mere breakdown of a live-in relationship does not automatically establish rape.
Q2. Is refusing to marry after a live-in relationship a criminal offence?
No. A subsequent refusal to marry does not, by itself, establish a criminal offence. The court examines whether the promise was allegedly made dishonestly from the beginning and whether the statutory ingredients are satisfied.
Q3. What is Section 69 BNS in a false promise of marriage case?
Section 69 BNS criminalises sexual intercourse by deceitful means or by making a promise to marry a woman without any intention of fulfilling it, where the conduct does not amount to rape.
Q4. Can a man seek anticipatory bail in a false promise of marriage case?
Depending on the allegations and circumstances, an accused may seek anticipatory bail under Section 482 BNSS.
Q5. Can the High Court quash an FIR registered after a consensual live-in relationship?
The High Court may exercise its inherent jurisdiction under Section 528 BNSS where the legal requirements for quashing are met. The decision depends on the allegations, available material and applicable law.
About Allies for Justice (AFJ)
Allies for Justice (AFJ) is a law firm providing legal assistance and representation in criminal litigation, matrimonial disputes, family law, civil and commercial disputes and other legal matters.
Our practice includes representation before the Supreme Court of India, Delhi High Court, trial courts and courts and tribunals across India.
For legal assistance concerning criminal complaints, false allegations, live-in relationship disputes, anticipatory bail and criminal defence, contact our legal team.
Allies for Justice (AFJ)
Advocates & Legal Consultants
Website: www.alliesforjustice.com
Email: alliesforjustice.afj@gmail.com
Contact: 8527706198 | 8285728233
Disclaimer: This article is intended solely for general legal awareness and informational purposes. It does not constitute legal advice or create an advocate-client relationship. The outcome of any case depends on its specific facts and applicable law.
Legal References
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 – Sections 28, 63 and 69.
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 – Sections 482 and 528.
- Kunal Rameshbhai Kalyani v. State of Gujarat & Anr., 2026 INSC 987, decided on 7 September 2026.
- Deepak Gulati v. State of Haryana, (2013) 7 SCC 675.
